|
06
Jul |
} | Modern Day Sweatbox |
I recently bought a scanner to do pencil tests on, and it’s working out nicely. So I thought I’d recommend it to anyone looking at animating on paper. You’ll likely be in the market for something similar someday. I followed this guide, and set out looking for an Auto Document Feed scanner that could handle 12 Field paper (10.5” x 12.5”). This meant I had three criteria in my search: It had to be cheap because I’m a student, it had to have ADF so I could spend more time animating (learning), and it had to be Wide Format so I could fit the animation paper in it. To make a long story short, after searching the internet, and checking out every store in town, I settled on this:

This in the Brother MFC-6490. It matched all my criteria, most important of which was cost, only setting me back $250. That’s a steal considering the prices for these kinds of scanners used to be in the thousands of dollars range. Now I spend all day animating and studying this:
And when I need to test my work, I just stack everything in the tray on top, and my pencil test is ready in a few minutes. I remember doing a tests with a camera back in film school, and how long that took. So much time was wasted that could have been used animating or learning something new. I hate wasting time, so I’m super happy with this purchase. I couldn’t find anything like this from HP, Epson, or Canon, so I think this is the only one on the market in that price range.
I’m super excited about posting some animation tests, but that will have to wait a bit. I feel I should get past the really basic boring stuff before I post anything. Plus I suck, which doesn’t motivate me to share my shiny terds.



Tuesday, July 7, 2009, 5 44:am UTC
Cameron Chamberlain
Cool, when did you get animators survival kit animated?
Is it as ridiculously amazing as it looks?
why do you animate on paper as opposed to wacom tablet? (not knocking it by any means, just curious)
- Cam
Tuesday, July 7, 2009, 5 47:am UTC
Cameron Chamberlain
oh, and last question; what are you compiling your tests in?
- Cam
Tuesday, July 7, 2009, 8 06:am UTC
Dan
Hey Cameron,
I use Digicel Flipbook, which is free, but also because it automatically aligns the scanned paper by the holes at the bottom, so everything always registers correctly. It’s really cool, and another automation that makes this process a lot easier than it used to be. I’d love to try animating on a Cintiq, but I think that will have to wait until I have two grand to spend on one. My heart is with animation on paper right now, I’m kind of a purist. I also think it looks better, and has a more artistic touch than any other way of animating with the exception of maybe claymation. The animator’s survival kit is wicked, a lot of work, but really cool. I’m doing as many of the exercises I can. I can’t do them all, like they did, or I’ll never get to my film.
Thursday, July 9, 2009, 4 32:pm UTC
David Nethery
WOW ! $250.00 for an 11″ x 17″ scanner ? That is a great find , Dan.
I’m almost tempted to pick one up and keep it mint-in-the-box as a spare in case my other scanner goes down.
Thanks for posting about the Brother MFC 6490 CW, which is a new one to me.
And by the way, I’ve got a Cintiq, I like it, I use it a lot … but animating traditionally on paper RULES ! Plus when the film is finished you get something tangible that you can hold in your hands to flip or (if it’s good enough) frame certain drawings and put them on a wall. Or sell them. Can’t do that with a bunch of 0′s and 1′s.
Thursday, July 9, 2009, 6 35:pm UTC
Dan
Haha! I knew you’d like this David. I’m so glad I found it when I did. I was SO close to buying an old Canon one for like $600 off craigslist and having it shipped from Georgia.
Friday, July 10, 2009, 3 36:pm UTC
David Nethery
Definitely. I’m passing this along to other students and teachers I know of who would find this to be of interest. Like I said to one person I told about it : even if the Brother MFC 6490 CW broke down and you had to replace it you could replace it several times over for the price of one of the usual 11 x 17 scanners from Epson , Fujitsu, Ricoh, etc. Please let me know if you encounter any quirks or problems with it as you’re scanning your pencil tests. Sounds like it’s working out great so far. One thing I’m excited about is that my favorite animation app , TVP Animation, is introducing Auto Peg Hole Alignment into the next update of the software (I’ve tried the beta version and it works great). Before now they have had a work-around system using the Pixel Tracker/2-Point Stabilization feature in TVP which can be used to register peg holes for drawings scanned off-pegs, but it was a sort of convoluted multi-step workaround , so now that they will have Peg Hole tracking and registration as an automatic function it makes TVP even more useful . I’ve used the Digicel Flipbook AutoScan peg hole registration system before and it works very well, too. Nothing beats an ADF scanner for speed . Up until now it’s just been the huge cost of an 11 x 17 ADF scanner that has kept it off-limits for most students and independent animators.
Again, great find Dan ! Thanks for sharing.
Friday, July 10, 2009, 4 06:pm UTC
Dan
Oh good, I’m looking forward to trying a different app. I only use Flipbook because of that feature, the program is very basic and annoying other than that. I’ll keep you posted.
Saturday, July 11, 2009, 10 48:am UTC
David Nethery
You can download and try the trial version of TVP Animation for free, but the restriction is that all the features are functional, but you just can’t save or export any work in the trial version. (but note that the Auto Peg Hole Registration won’t be introduced until the next update, so the present trial version doesn’t have it , but if you want to know how to do the workaround with the “2-Point Stabilization pixel tracker” I can email you instructions).
Which version of Digicel Flipbook are you using ? I think the one called “Flipbook Lite” is a bit limiting, but the full version of Digicel Flipbook Studio is pretty useful and Flipbook Pro is even better. Actually I think Flipbook is fine, more than adequate for doing pencil testing. If you’re only going to be doing pencil tests then TVP may be overkill. (I use TVP because it allows me to go back and forth between the traditional paper and digital paperless drawing modes effortlessly. As I said , I spend a lot of my time these days on the Cintiq, so I prefer the more advanced digital drawing tools in TVP. Flipbook Studio has some basic pencil tools for tablet-based drawing, but it’s not in the same league as TVP for that purpose. But for basic pencil testing of traditional pencil-on-paper animation I think Flipbook is pretty good. I’m curious what is it you don’t like about it ? (I’m always interested in reading feedback from animation students so I can continue to make good recommendations to students in my current or upcoming classes … )
By the way, if you do decide to buy TVP Animation be sure to let them know you are a student when purchasing. The EDU discount is significant . As a student you can get TVP Pro for MUCH less than the regular retail price.
Saturday, July 11, 2009, 11 49:am UTC
Dan
I just don’t find it very user friendly, it’s also very basic. I don’t think I have the lite version, but I don’t think I have pro. I’ll have to check when I get home. Eventually I’ll probably get a Cintiq, so I might as well get TVP and get used to it. For now I’m just doing pencil tests, so yeah, Flipbook does the job just fine. But I can see myself quickly outgrowing it.
Animating on paper is just too cool, I would like to ink and paint a little test, nothing big, just to do it. But who knows if I ever will.
Friday, August 28, 2009, 2 20:pm UTC
Simon
Greetings,
Thanks SO much for posting about this. I’m post anim school grad and professionally do 3d animation, but personally YEARN to get back to pencil and paper. I just get more out of it than digital, I’m not exactly sure why. Being out of school I tried to get the necessary tools together, but a camera and stand were a problem for me. When I checked on scanners like this a couple years ago they were so astronomic in price I laughed. But this, combined with peghole recognition software, make it really doable. So, thanks man.
One question: Is the scan level only good for pencil tests or is it high enough to use for final animation?
Thanks again!!
Friday, August 28, 2009, 4 03:pm UTC
Dan
Hey no problem, man. It’s so affordable I had to post about it. Plus I knew people like David (above) would get a kick out of it. I love hand drawn animation, and I know what you mean. You should check out the product page at the Brother website for specifics. I’ve only used it for pencil tests so far, nothing final yet, so I can’t say with complete certainty, but I think it will handle anything you need to do. Mine is packed (moving) so I can’t check, but I know you can scan at least 600 DPI on it.
Saturday, August 28, 2010, 5 12:am UTC
Martin Shellabarger
If you get the Brother scanner/printer, make sure it is the right one! They also have a model which prints 11 x 16 (over here in Europe it is A3), but the scanner is only 8.5 x 12 (A4). Unfortunately I did not know this, and the salesman assured me that this was what I was asking about, and I ended up with the wrong machine. I’ll either use it as a backup/main duty machine or give it to my wife for her printer/scanner, and get the right one next time I have the money. Luckily the thing is so inexpensive that shouldn’t take too long!
One thing I noticed about my machine, and is probably the same on all of them, is that the paper tray is rather flimsy, and looks like it could break if you are not gentle with it.
I used to be a Technical Support Specialist and Technical Manager for computer stores, and can vouch for the brand. Brother has always been good.
Monday, August 30, 2010, 5 45:pm UTC
Daniel Caylor
@Martin: Great tips. Thanks!